Quantification of the PBAP contribution to giant CCN An analysis of the contribution to simulated freezing rates at the sites of the field

We thank the editor for the opportunity to respond to reviewer comments and for taking the time to consider a revised manuscript. We also thank the reviewers for their time and for their comments on our manuscript. We respond to the reviewer comments in detail below. To guide the review process, reviewer comments are in italics, our responses are in normal text. We also attach a revised manuscript with tracked changes.